Now that the Toronto Wolves are established with Chip Kelly and Troy Aikman running things, our series “Building An NFL Expansion Team” continues today with Part II: The Expansion Draft.
Rules
First, we need rules; like the 2002 NFL expansion draft, each existing NFL team must list five players that can be selected, but a) they cannot be a kicker/punter, b) cannot be entering free agency after the season, and c) cannot be coming off injured reserve from the previous year.
Also, the list may only include one player with more than ten years of NFL experience. Once a player is selected from an existing team, they may remove one of the remaining players from the list. And if two players from the same team are selected, the remaining players are allowed to be removed (but don’t need to be).
For the Wolves, we will need to either draft 30 players or $67.4 million worth of contracts (38% of the 2018 salary cap).
Available Players
Obviously, these won’t be 100% accurate in regards to what each NFL team would really do if there were an expansion draft, but the player pool that meets all criteria is pretty limited, so it should be close. This process would have been done before the 2018 NFL Draft and free agency, so this is based on returning players from last year’s 53-man rosters.
Arizona Cardinals
LB Josh Bynes
S Rudy Ford
OT Will Holden
G Mike Iupati
CB Brandon Williams
Atlanta Falcons
DT Jack Crawford
CB Demontae Kazee
RB Terrance Magee
DE Brooks Reed
TE Eric Saubert
Baltimore Ravens
ILB Bam Bradley
S Chuck Clark
CB Jaylen Hill
DE Bronson Kaufusi
DT Patrick Ricard
Buffalo Bills
DE Rickey Hatley
WR Andre Holmes
DE Shaq Lawson
RB Marcus Murphy
MLB Tanner Vallejo
Carolina Panthers
FB Alex Armah
S Demetrius Cox
OT Matt Kalil
LS J.J. Jansen
CB Captain Munnerlyn
Chicago Bears
S Deon Bush
S Deiondre’ Hall
RB Taquan Mizzell
TE Dion Sims
WR Kevin White
Cincinnati Bengals
TE Cethan Carter
WR Cody Core
CB KeiVarae Russell
G Christian Westerman
RB Brandon Wilson
Cleveland Browns
DT Caleb Brantley
RB Matt Dayes
LS Charley Hughlett
QB Cody Kessler
WR Ricardo Louis
Dallas Cowboys
WR Dez Bryant
WR Noah Brown
TE Blake Jarwin
WR Lance Lenoir
DE Charles Tapper
Denver Broncos
S Jamal Carter
RB De’Angelo Henderson
FB Andy Janovich
WR Isaiah McKenzie
OT Menelik Watson
Detroit Lions
WR Jace Billingsley
WR Andy Jones
S Miles Killebrew
DT Jeremiah Ledbetter
RB Dwayne Washington
Green Bay Packers
WR Trevor Davis
RB Devante Mays
OT Kyle Murphy
WR Jordy Nelson
CB Lenzy Pipkins
Houston Texans
G Kyle Fuller
ILB LaTroy Lewis
FB Jay Prosch
G Chad Slade
WR Chris Thompson
Indianapolis Colts
TE Darrell Daniels
CB Kenny Moore
DT Grover Stewart
LB Anthony Walker
CB D.J. White
Jacksonville Jaguars
DT Eli Ankou
LB Blair Brown
DT Marcell Dareus
CB Jalen Myrick
MLB Donald Payne
Kansas City Chiefs
ILB Ukeme Eligwe
OT Cameron Erving
CB Eric Murray
WR Demarcus Robinson
LS James Winchester
Los Angeles Chargers
TE Sean Culkin
CB Michael Davis
S Rayshawn Jenkins
OT Sam Tevi
FB Derek Watt
Los Angeles Rams
C Austin Blythe
S Marqui Christian
RB Justin Davis
DT Tanzel Smart
WR Mike Thomas
Miami Dolphins
LB Chase Allen
CB Torry McTyer
S Maurice Smith
DT Ndamukong Suh
DT Vincent Taylor
Minnesota Vikings
DE Tashawn Bower
WR Stacy Coley
OT Aviante Collins
DE Stephen Weatherly
LB Eric Wilson
New England Patriots
TE Dwayne Allen
OT Cole Croston
G Ted Karras
LB Harvey Langi
DE Deatrich Wise
New Orleans Saints
S Vonn Bell
RB Trey Edmunds
WR Ted Ginn
LB A.J. Klein
DT Al-Quadin Muhammad
New York Giants
TE Jerell Adams
TE Rhett Ellison
DE Avery Moss
MLB Calvin Munson
OT Chad Wheeler
New York Jets
CB Justin Burris
CB Jeremy Clark
LS Thomas Hennessy
CB Derrick Jones
WR Charone Peake
Oakland Raiders
WR Michael Crabtree
DT Treyvon Hester
S Shalom Luani
OT David Sharpe
OT Jylan Ware
Philadelphia Eagles
WR Shelton Gibson
LB Kamu Grugier-Hill
DT Elijah Qualls
G Isaac Seumalo
RB Wendell Smallwood
Pittsburgh Steelers
CB Brian Allen
OLB Bud Dupree
CB Mike Hilton
ILB Tyler Matakevich
TE Vance McDonald
San Francisco 49ers
WR Victor Bolden
DT D.J. Jones
LB Elijah Lee
OT Erik Magnuson
LB Pita Taumoepenu
Seattle Seahawks
DE Michael Bennett
WR Amara Darboh
G Jordan Roos
S Tedric Thompson
TE Nick Vannett
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
TE Antony Auclair
OT Caleb Benenoch
LB Devante Bond
DE William Gholston
WR DeSean Jackson
Tennessee Titans
ILB Daren Bates
OLB Josh Carraway
OLB Kevin Dodd
CB LeShaun Sims
OLB Aaron Wallace
Washington Redskins
G Tyler Catalina
WR Robert Davis
ILB Josh Harvey-Clemons
CB Joshua Holsey
LS Nick Sundberg
The Expansion Draft
Now, I’ll go through the picks and give a description for why each player was drafted. If you didn’t remember from Part I, Chip Kelly is our head coach and Dick LeBeau is our defensive coordinator, so we will have a spread offense and a 3-4 defense. [Note: 2018 cap hit from original team (if they were released/traded) is in parenthesis]
Pick 1: Jordy Nelson, WR, Packers ($12,500,000)
This is an easy pick to start off the team. I think Green Bay will quickly regret getting rid of Jordy, who has been drawing rave reviews with the Raiders.
Pick 2: Cody Kessler, QB, Browns ($758,098)
Another easy pick here, as I have always been a fan of Cody Kessler, and he’s the only quarterback available in the expansion draft. At worst, the former third-round pick will be a high-end backup.
Pick 3: Rhett Ellison, TE, Giants ($3,750,000)
Rhett Ellison will make an immediate impact in Chip Kelly’s offense as one of the best blocking tight ends in the league. I thought about getting former San Francisco tight end Vance McDonald instead, but the Steelers pulled him after this next pick.
Pick 4: Mike Hilton, CB, Steelers ($555,000)
Pittsburgh easily had the best collection of players on the list, and it was a difficult task choosing the five players. Our new franchise benefits from that by getting an emerging slot corner in Mike Hilton.
Pick 5: Anthony Walker, ILB, Colts ($621,353)
The Colts would love to keep Anthony Walker around, but like the Steelers, they needed to make some tough choices. The 2017 fourth-rounder will start at inside linebacker.
Pick 6: Ted Ginn, WR, Saints ($4,500,000)
New Orleans also had to expose some solid players, and Ted Ginn will operate as a deep threat in Kelly’s attack.
Pick 7: Kevin Dodd, OLB, Titans ($1,489,160)
Kevin Dodd was recently released by the Titans, but I would have drafted him to see if we can unlock his potential. The former Clemson product was the No. 33 pick in the 2016 NFL Draft.
Pick 8: Brandon Williams, CB, Cardinals ($824,173)
Another former Day 2 pick that hasn’t reached his potential, I think Brandon Williams could thrive on the outside of Dick LeBeau’s defense.
Pick 9: Tyler Matakevich, ILB, Steelers ($645,762)
Again, the Steelers get another key player swiped away, as Tyler Matakevich will compliment Anthony Walker at inside linebacker and provide elite value on special teams.
Pick 10: Kevin White, WR, Bears ($5,270,060)
Why not try to take advantage of a healthy Kevin White? The former No. 7 overall pick has flashed when he’s been on the field.
Pick 11: Dwayne Allen, TE, Patriots ($5,000,000)
There aren’t any big-time receiving threats available to pair with Rhett Ellison, but Dwayne Allen has been a productive, all-around player since entering the league.
Pick 12: Dwayne Washington, RB, Lions ($648,941)
We will probably have to target the running back position aggressively in free agency and/or the draft, but Dwayne Washington can bring value on special teams as the third or fourth guy.
Pick 13: Justin Davis, RB, Rams ($560,000)
Justin Davis could be a change-of-pace option in the backfield, as he showed potential as a slasher last preseason with nine carries for 70 yards against the Cowboys.
Pick 14: Brooks Reed, OLB, Falcons ($3,940,000)
The veteran should bring plenty of effort and excellent depth as both a pass rusher and special teamer.
Pick 15: Menelik Watson, OT, Broncos ($7,177,083)
It’s time to start building the offensive line as best we can. Menelik Watson carries a big cap hit, but we can certainly afford it. He should be the starter at right tackle.
Pick 16: Elijah Qualls, DT, Eagles ($586,801)
We need to get pieces on the defensive line, too, and Elijah Qualls should be able to start at either defensive end or nose tackle for an expansion team.
Pick 17: Amara Darboh, WR, Seahawks ($754,572)
Former Michigan standout Amar Darboh provides special teams value and insurance in the case of a Kevin White injury.
Pick 18: Matt Kalil, OT, Panthers ($6,900,000)
Matt Kalil wasn’t great last year for Carolina—which is why he was made available—but we can take his cap hit and hopefully see a career resurgence in a new city.
Pick 19: Cameron Erving, OT, Chiefs ($1,720,781)
I’m not sure what position would be best for Cameron Erving, but he can fight for a role all along the offensive line, as spots will be up for grabs.
Pick 20: Christian Westerman, G, Bengals ($687,924)
Despite starting just two games so far with the Bengals, I think 2016 fifth-round pick Christian Westerman could eventually turn into a solid player on the interior.
Pick 21: Deon Bush, S, Bears ($761,554)
Deon Bush didn’t get many defensive snaps with Chicago in 2017, but he started six games as a rookie and is the best option on the back end for us in the expansion draft.
Pick 22: Tyler Catalina, G, Redskins ($555,000)
Back to the offensive line, Tyler Catalina went undrafted last year, but he ended up starting two games for Washington. The Massachusetts native should be ready for the cold weather in Toronto.
Pick 23: Austin Blythe, C, Rams ($630,000)
Rounding out the offensive line (current starters are listed below), Austin Blythe brings the toughness we want as a four-year starter at Iowa.
Pick 24: Jeremy Clark, CB, Jets ($592,103)
Cornerback will be a target in free agency or the NFL Draft, as we need someone to start alongside Mike Hilton and Brandon Williams. However, Jeremy Clark could be an underrated addition after missing most of his rookie year with a torn ACL suffered in college.
Pick 25: Erik Magnuson, OT, 49ers ($556,333)
Erik Magnuson should provide quality depth at tackle or guard as a former Big Ten offensive lineman in a six-foot-six frame.
Pick 26: Kamu Grugier-Hill, ILB, Eagles ($630,000)
The Eagles probably would pull Isaac Seumalo after we took Elijah Qualls earlier, but core special teamer Kamu Grugier-Hill is worth drafting as the second player from the defending champs.
Pick 27: Chuck Clark, S, Ravens ($598,705)
In real life, Chuck Clark could have a bigger role with the Ravens in 2018, but we take him to pair with Deon Bush at safety.
Pick 28: William Gholston, DE, Buccaneers ($6,500,000)
Finally, we decide to take a chance on William Gholston to get us to $69,713,403 million for the cap. The veteran is coming off a sub-par season in his first year of a five-year extension, but if kicking him inside to defensive end in our 3-4 scheme doesn’t work out, we can move on from him without a cap penalty.
Roster (So Far)
We will still get a shot at free agents and, of course, the 2018 rookie class in the NFL Draft, but this is how the foundation of the roster looks for the Toronto Wolves right now.
Offense
QB: Cody Kessler
RB: Dwayne Washington // Justin Davis
WR: Jordy Nelson
WR: Ted Ginn
WR: Kevin White // Amara Darboh
TE: Rhett Ellison // Dwayne Allen
LT: Matt Kalil // Cameron Erving
LG: Christian Westerman
C: Austin Blythe
RG: Tyler Catalina
RT: Menelik Watson // Erik Magnuson
Defense
DE: William Gholston
DT: Elijah Qualls
OLB: Kevin Dodd
ILB: Anthony Walker // Kamu Grugier-Hill
ILB: Tyler Matakevich
OLB: Brooks Reed
CB: Brandon Williams
CB: Jeremy Clark
CB: Mike Hilton
S: Deon Bush
S: Chuck Clark
Be sure to return tomorrow for Part III to see what the Toronto Wolves do in free agency.
Team is kind of weak. That’s why David Carr struggled years ago.
True. He didn’t have much to work with in Houston.
Enjoyable read so far.
Dope
Wow that’s tough.
This is awesome! Only question I have is why you decided to expose Ted Ginn? Solid year last year and a pretty reasonable contract. Were the Saints in cap trouble?
Thanks a lot for reading! Just as I said for the pick of Ginn, the Saints had to expose some solid players because of the protection rules that forced them to. I went with Ginn over a couple other options because he’s 33 and there would have hopefully been some other speed receivers in free agency (John Brown, Taylor Gabriel) or the draft that could’ve replaced him in Sean Payton’s offense.